Cash vs. Accrual Basis Accounting for Small Businesses - financepal

Cash vs. Accrual Basis Accounting for Small Businesses

December 9th, 2019

Written by:

As a small business owner, one of the many important financial decisions you’ll make is whether to use cash vs. accrual basis accounting. For many business owners, this can be a roadblock when getting started. Whether you’re unaware of what the difference between these two accounting methods even is or just need more background on how they work, we have you covered.

Put simply, the difference between accrual vs. cash basis accounting comes down to the timing of transaction recording. In accrual basis accounting, transactions are recorded as soon as an exchange is initiated. However, in cash basis accounting, transactions aren’t recorded until money is sent or received.

While making accounting decisions with little to no financial experience might seem overwhelming, we’ve created this guide on cash vs. accrual accounting for small business owners to simplify the choice.

If you’re unfamiliar with these concepts, we highly recommend taking a deep dive into this article. But, if you’re short on time and have a specific question you need answered, use these links to navigate to the section you need:

What’s the Difference Between Cash Basis and Accrual Basis Accounting?

Cash Basis Accounting

Accrual Basis Accounting

Should Small Businesses Use Cash or Accrual Accounting?

Which Accounting Method Is Better, Cash or Accrual?

Can You Switch from Cash to Accrual?

How Can FinancePal Help Your Business with Accounting?

Move Forward with the Right Accounting Method for Your Business

What’s the Difference Between Cash Basis and Accrual Basis Accounting?

The difference between cash basis and accrual basis accounting is when transactions are recorded:

    • Cash Basis Accounting: Transactions are recorded when cash comes in or goes out of your business.
    • Accrual Basis Accounting: Transactions are recorded in the period they occurred, regardless of whether money exchanged hands or not.

When choosing an accounting method for your business, you will need to carefully consider the pros and cons of accrual vs. cash basis accounting, which we’ll cover shortly.

But first, let’s go through a quick example comparing how the same transaction would be recording using the two different methods:

Say your business was contracted for a job on February 1st, in which the client is quoted $5,000. Of that $5,000, $3,500 is the cost of labor and materials to complete the job. Based on that, your business’s profit will be $1,500. The client pays for the work on March 1st.

    • Cash Basis Accounting: Revenue ($1,500) would not be recorded until March 1st. However, you could choose to record your expenses on February 1st or March 1st, depending on your preferences. If you recorded your expenses ($3,500) before your received payment, your overall performance would seem lower for February.
    • Accrual Basis Accounting: Both revenue and expenses would need to be recorded on February 1st.

But what does it mean to “record a transaction”? Since this is a core concept for understanding how these two methods of accounting work, we should take a moment to explain.

What Is a Transaction and Why Is It Recorded?

An accounting transaction is any business activity that has a financial impact on your operations. Every transaction is recorded as part of the accounting cycle in order to keep track of your business’s financial standing.

Typically, a bookkeeper will be responsible for analyzing and recording transactions, as well as all the other steps necessary to manage your books. Bookkeeping is an essential function of your business in order to generate financial statements for each period.

Note: If you need to back up even further and figure out the difference between bookkeeping vs. accounting, we have a guide for that. As the small business financial experts, we’re here to make it easy on you.

Now, let’s break down each of these accounting methods into more detail…

Cash Basis Accounting

In cash basis accounting, transactions are recorded when money is spent or received. This means that when using cash basis accounting, money paid is only recorded when it leaves your bank account and money received for goods or services is only recorded once it is in your bank account.

In other words, cash basis accounting records transactions when money officially changes hands.

Cash basis accounting is usually used for managing personal finances. For instance, it’s the method you’d use to balance your checkbook.

Examples of Cash Basis Accounting

To drive this concept home, let’s take a look at some real-world examples:

  1. Imagine that you own a bar. When patrons come in and place an order for a round of drinks, they pay the tab immediately (or at least before they leave at the end of the night). For this transaction, say their tab was $100. You would record a $100 transaction for that date.
  2. Let’s say you placed an order for dishware for your new restaurant. Your order it on January 1st, but you don’t pay the invoice until February 1st. In this case, the transaction for the expenditure is recorded as February 1st.
  3. Now, let’s take it from a different perspective. If you lease an office space, you likely pay monthly rent. With cash basis accounting, this transaction would be recorded each month on the date the money leaves your account.

Pros of Cash Basis Accounting

The benefits of using cash accrual accounting include:

    • Like we mentioned before, you’re likely already familiar with how this method is used for your personal finances.
    • You know how much cash is currently available. This is good for understanding short-term finances.
    • You won’t pay taxes on income until it’s received. This way you don’t have to worry about not being able to afford the taxes on a large order you haven’t been paid for yet.

Another way that cash basis accounting can benefit small business owners is on their tax bill. To lower your current year’s tax payments, you could request that clients hold off on making payments until the beginning of the year.

Cons of Cash Basis Accounting

However, there are also disadvantages to the cash accrual method:

    • Doesn’t provide an accurate financial picture. This can make it difficult to make projections for your business.
    • Lack of invoicing structure. There are no accounts receivable or accounts payable records to keep track of outstanding bills and payments.
    • Doesn’t meet the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). However, this is because it doesn’t have to. (We’ll discuss the revenue threshold that puts these rules into effect.)

Key Takeaways for Cash Basis Accounting:

With cash basis accounting you’ll have a good view of actual cash flow, but you won’t have an accurate report of your sales and inventory. This means more time digging into the numbers when you need a sharper picture of the details. This is because you’ve recorded purchases made using credit (the money has not yet come out of the account) or because you’ve extended credit to your customers that has not yet been paid for.

Accrual Basis Accounting

In accrual basis accounting, transactions are recorded when money is earned or an expense is incurred — not when the money is actually exchanged. Another way to think about it is that transactions are recorded as soon as there is a legal obligation to pay.

Basically, transactions are recorded based on the assumption that they will get paid.

When using accrual basis accounting, accounts receivable and accounts payable are used to record these transactions.

Examples of Accrual Basis Accounting

For clarity, let’s take a look at a few real-world examples:

  1. First, let’s focus on accounts receivable (when someone owes you money). Suppose a client places an order on January 1st for some products they want to carry in their store. With an accrual basis system, you would record the transaction as accounts receivable on January 1st.
  2. Imagine that your cleaning business receives a new contract with a client who schedules out cleaning services for the next month. You would record the transaction this month, with the expectation that you will receive the payment next month once the service is complete.
  3. Now let’s shift our focus to accounts payable (when you owe someone money). Say you’re the one ordering product; you would record the transaction on the same day that you placed the order, not when you pay the invoice.

Pros of Accrual Basis Accounting

Accrual basis accounting has its own advantages:

    • Provides a more accurate picture of the business’s overall financial health. This will come in handy when you’re trying to make big financial decisions, especially those that will significantly impact your business’s future.
    • Meets GAAP standards. This is required because better tracking of inventory sales is needed.
    • Better for large businesses. The more transactions your business has coming in and out, the more likely accrual basis accounting will be better for keeping everything organized and accounted for.

Because they are able to get better financial overview of your company, investors typically prefer this method.

Like cash basis accounting, there are also disadvantages to this method.

Cons of Accrual Basis Accounting

The disadvantages of accrual basis accounting include:

    • More complicated. Because payments haven’t actually been made or received, there is an added layer of complexity you must keep in mind.
    • Poor short-term view of finances. With the accrual method, you won’t have a clear view of your business’s cash flow.
    • Bank account doesn’t match your books. Since you’re recording transactions that you haven’t paid out or received money for yet, you could think you have more money on hand than you actually do.

Key Takeaways for Accrual Basis Accounting

When using accrual basis accounting, you could end up with a significant amount of revenue but very little cash on hand if clients take a long time to pay you.

To counterbalance this potential challenge, you want to be more diligent about monitoring your cash flow. Reviewing the cash you have on hand on a weekly basis should be sufficient to help you avoid that trouble, though.

Note: For other tips on how to properly manage cash flow, or correct course, read our comprehensive guide to small business cash flow.

Cash vs. accrual accounting have pretty significant differences. With their clearly defined advantages and disadvantages, it should be fairly easy to determine which is better suited for your business.

Should Small Businesses Use Cash or Accrual Accounting?

Trying to decide between cash vs. accrual for your small business accounting? Typically, smaller businesses use cash basis accounting, and larger businesses prefer accrual basis. Here are some further factors to consider when trying to choose between cash vs. accrual:

    • Does your business carry a lot of inventory? – If yes, you’ll probably be better off with the accrual method.
    • Do you have a seasonal business with periods when there’s little to no activity? – If yes, you should probably stick with cash accounting.
    • Will you be selling your business soon? – If yes, accrual might be a better option.
    • Are you planning to apply for financing soon? – If yes, accrual is probably best.
    • Is your business a non-profit that needs to closely monitor cash? – If yes, you should probably opt for cash basis accounting.
    • Is it reasonable to expect that your company may go public in the near future? – If yes, you are likely best off with accrual basis accounting.

However, every business is different. What might be right for one small business doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the right solution for yours. Certain businesses have very simple finances which might be well-suited for the cash basis accounting method.

At the end of the day, accrual accounting will demand more from business owners. The more transactions you need to keep up with, the more time it will demand from your already busy schedule. This is why it is typically recommended that you work with an accountant once your business begins to grow.

Requirements for Accrual vs. Cash Basis Accounting

It’s important to know that if, or when, your business reaches $5 million in annual revenue, you will be required to use the accrual method. If you’ve reported revenue below $5 million for the last three years, you’re okay to use cash basis accounting if you want to.

This requirement is based on the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) set forth by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). These standards dictate how financial statements are prepared and presented.

Which Accounting Method Is Better, Cash or Accrual?

Generally speaking, accrual vs. cash basis accounting doesn’t come down to which is necessarily better in an overarching sense, but on a case-by-case basis. For example, even the Congressional Budget Office must decide between which of these accounting methods is the best for different aspects of their budget. During the federal budgeting process, this is done depending on the specific program, not as a blanketed approach.

In some cases, some business owners choose to use a hybrid approach for their accounting. This is possible by using accrual basis accounting for inventory-related transactions and the cash basis accounting for revenue- and expense-related transactions.

If you are going to take the hybrid approach, it’s likely that you’ll need professional help as your books become more complicated. Making sure that every transaction is recorded correctly is essential to your business’s financial health.

So, when it comes down to it, determining whether cash basis or accrual basis accounting is better depends on your business’s unique circumstances.

Can You Switch from Cash to Accrual?

Yes, you can. You might decide to switch from cash to accrual accounting if:

    • You realize you’ve made the wrong choice for your business when choosing between accrual vs. cash basis accounting.
    • Your business has grown to the point that you feel accrual basis accounting would be a better fit.
    • You’ve hit the $5 million revenue threshold and are required to change over.

However, it’s important to note that you’re required to use the same accounting method for an entire tax year. So, if you’re looking to switch from cash to accrual, you’ll need to plan accordingly.

You can also switch your books from accrual to cash basis accounting. This might be the case if the accrual method turns out to be overly complicated for your business’s purposes.

Note: If you do hit the profit threshold, this is where accurate financial statements and forecasting will become especially important. If you believe you’ll hit this revenue in the coming year, you’ll need to start a plan to switch over your accounting method.

Is It Difficult to Switch Accounting Methods?

Whether switching accounting methods is difficult depends on your experience and understanding of bookkeeping and accounting.

To make it easier on you, we’ve laid out the general process for switching accounting methods below:

How Do You Switch from Cash to Accrual Accounting?

A few steps are required to make this transition:

  1. File Form 3115 with the IRS. The form either needs to be submitted at some point during the year in which you switch your accounting method, or attached to your federal income taxes. You will also need to submit a copy to the IRS National Office. Without a formal request and approval, you might be subject to penalties.
    1. Typically, it’s recommended that you submit the form as early as possible to allow for any potential hiccups in the process.
    2. In addition to Form 311, you should also provide your income statement for the year and a record of your accrued income and expenses for the year.
  2. Adjust your books. If you’re going to switch over your accounting method, you’ll need to adjust your books to the new method. To do this, you’ll need to:
    1. Calculate your accrued income for the tax year.
    2. Calculate your accrued expenses for the tax year.
    3. Add these together to calculate the total adjustment you’ll need to make your business’s income as previously calculated using the cash method.
  3. Complete section 481 on Form 3115 to reflect this adjustment.

Looks like a lot, doesn’t it? Luckily, you don’t have to figure it all out on your own. In fact, FinancePal can handle your business’s accounting for you.

Find out why so many small businesses choose FinancePal to handle their bookkeeping, accounting, and more…

How Can FinancePal Help Your Business with Accounting?

Working with FinancePal means that you have a team of experts helping you tackle your business’s accounting. Here’s how you can benefit from turning over your accounting to FinancePal:

    • All of your business transactions will be recorded and reconciled through digital bookkeeping.
    • You can rest assured that your books and financial statements will be accurate.
    • Review your business’s current financial position with weekly and monthly financial statements.
    • Access to an easy-to-use, efficient online platform.
    • Maximize tax-saving opportunities.
    • Save money by forgoing a full-time bookkeeper and accountant.
    • Access to a dedicated team of experts.
    • Receive services tailored to your business’s needs.

As you can see, our mission is to make managing your business’s finances as simple as possible. By using FinancePal, you’ll save time that can be invested in other critical aspects of running and growing your business. This can prove invaluable, especially in the early years of your business.

How Much Will Accounting with FinancePal Cost?

Our goal is to make high-quality financial assistance accessible to small business owners on all budgets. While your first instinct might be that you can’t afford to hire help with accounting, FinancePal has a tiered pricing system starting at just $99 per month.

In addition to small business accounting, FinancePal provides entity formation, payroll solutions, sales and use tax consulting, and bookkeeping services for small businesses. We’re your one-stop-shop for small business financial management — and we make it simple.

Move Forward with the Right Accounting Method for Your Business

Still unsure whether you should use cash or accrual accounting for your small business? Why spend time worrying when your business could be backed by FinancePal? Our experts can help you figure out how to move forward with your small business accounting.

About the Author

Jacob Dayan, Esq.

Jacob Dayan is a true Chicagoan, born and raised in the Windy City. After starting his career as a financial analyst in New York City, Jacob returned to Chicago and co-founded FinancePal in 2015. He graduated Magna Cum Laude from Mitchell Hamline School of Law, and is a licensed attorney in Illinois.

Jacob has crafted articles covering a variety of tax and finance topics, including resolution strategy, financial planning, and more. He has been featured in an array of publications, including Accounting Web, Yahoo, and Business2Community.

Read More

About the Author

Nick Charveron, EA

Nick Charveron is a licensed tax practitioner, Co-Founder & Partner of Community Tax, LLC. His Enrolled Agent designation is the highest tax credential offered by the U.S Department of Treasury, providing unrestricted practice rights before the IRS.

Read More

About the Author

Jason Gabbard, Founder and CEO of JUSTLAW

Jason Gabbard is a lawyer and the founder of JUSTLAW.

About the Author

Andrew Jordan, Chief Operations Officer at FinancePal

Andrew is an experienced CPA and has extensive executive leadership experience.

Recent Posts
Related Posts

Small Business Accounting Services

Learn More
Popular Posts

Powered by Industry-Leading Technology

Learn More

Don't just take our word for it.

Ready to give our services a try?

Contact us today to learn more about your free trial!

  • Get Started Today

      By entering your phone number and clicking the “Get Started” button, you provide your electronic signature and consent for FinancePal to contact you with information and offers at the phone number provided using an automated system, pre-recorded messages, and/or text messages. Consent is not required as a condition of purchase. Message and data rates may apply.